+ Gripes With Go +

You’ve read a lot of posts about the shortcomings of the Go programming language, so what’s one more.

Lack of sum types
Type assertions
Date and Time
Statements over Expressions
Erroring out on unused variables
Error handling

Lack of Sum types

A “Sum” type is a data type that can hold one of many states at a given time, similar to how a boolean can hold a true or a false, not too different from an enum type in C. Go lacks enum types unfortunately, and you are forced to resort to crafting your own substitute.

A type to represent gender for example:

type Gender int
+
+const (
+    Male Gender = iota  // assigns Male to 0
+    Female              // assigns Female to 1
+    Other               // assigns Other to 2
+)
+
+fmt.Println("My gender is ", Male)
+// My gender is 0
+// Oops! We have to implement String() for Gender ...
+
+func (g Gender) String() string {
+    switch (g) {
+    case 0: return "Male"
+    case 1: return "Female"
+    default: return "Other"
+    }
+}
+
+// You can accidentally do stupid stuff like:
+gender := Male + 1

The Haskell equivalent of the same:

data Gender = Male
+            | Female
+            | Other
+            deriving (Show)
+
+print $ "My gender is " ++ (show Male)

Type Assertions

A downcast with an optional error check? What could go wrong?

Type assertions in Go allow you to do:

var x interface{} = 7
+y, goodToGo := x.(int)
+if goodToGo {
+    fmt.Println(y)
+}

The error check however is optional:

var x interface{} = 7
+var y := x.(float64)
+fmt.Println(y)
+// results in a runtime error:
+// panic: interface conversion: interface {} is int, not float64

Date and Time

Anyone that has written Go previously, will probably already know what I am getting at here. For the uninitiated, parsing and formatting dates in Go requires a “layout”. This “layout” is based on magical reference date:

Mon Jan 2 15:04:05 MST 2006

Which is the date produced when you write the first seven natural numbers like so:

01/02 03:04:05 '06 -0700

Parsing a string in YYYY-MM-DD format would look something like:

const layout = "2006-01-02"
+time.Parse(layout, "2020-08-01")

This so-called “intuitive” method of formatting dates doesn’t allow you to print 0000 hrs as 2400 hrs, it doesn’t allow you to omit the leading zero in 24 hour formats. It is rife with inconveniences, if only there were a tried and tested date formatting convention …

Statements over Expressions

Statements have side effects, expressions return values. More often than not, expressions are easier to understand at a glance: evaluate the LHS and assign the same to the RHS.

Rust allows you to create local namespaces, and treats blocks ({}) as expressions:

let twenty_seven = {
+    let three = 1 + 2;
+    let nine = three * three;
+    nine * three
+};

The Go equivalent of the same:

twenty_seven := nil
+
+three := 1 + 2
+nine := three * three
+twenty_seven = nine * three

Erroring out on unused variables

Want to quickly prototype something? Go says no! In all seriousness, a warning would suffice, I don’t want to have to go back and comment each unused import out, only to come back and uncomment them a few seconds later.

Error handling

if err != nil { ... }

Need I say more? I will, for good measure:

Error handling is optional
Errors are propagated via a clunky if + return statement

I prefer Haskell’s “Monadic” error handling, which is employed by Rust as well:

// 1. error handling is compulsory
+// 2. errors are propagated with the `?` operator
+fn foo() -> Result<String, io::Error> {
+    let mut f = File::open("foo.txt")?; // return if error
+    let mut s = String::new();
+
+    f.read_to_string(&mut s)?; // return if error
+
+    Ok(s) // all good, return a string inside a `Result` context
+}
+
+fn main() {
+    // `contents` is an enum known as Result:
+    let contents = foo();
+    match contents {
+        Ok(c) => println!(c),
+        Err(e) => eprintln!(e)
+    }
+}

Conclusion

I did not want to conclude without talking about stylistic choices, lack of metaprogramming, bizzare export rules, but, I am too busy converting my interface{} types into actual generic code for Go v2.

+ +

+ Hi. +

+ Subscribe + Donate +

I'm Akshay, I go by nerd or nerdypepper on the internet.

+ I am a compsci undergrad, Rust programmer and an enthusiastic Vimmer. + I write open-source stuff to pass time. I also design fonts: scientifica, curie. +

Send me a mail at nerdy@peppe.rs or a message at nerdypepper@irc.rizon.net.

+ + ⟵ Back + View Raw +